The spring used on a CBBL seems to be very stout. The axis is a lot easier to use but has more components that could break but the cbbl seems a lot stronger to me but that's just my opinion. Jim Guy. I have always been a fan of the Yojimbo 2 but have been wary of the delicate tip. I have experienced this on my 940. The weak points in the cbbl is the polymer cage. I'm not a huge fan of framelocks or liner locks, as I'm a lefty and can't use those as easily. [ARCHIVED THREAD] - SPYDERCO Knives Compression Lock vs Ball Bearing Lock. Since I haven't done a long term assemsent on the CBBL (i.e. IMO it's not even close, and I love Spyderco as a company. Nothing a little bit practice wouldn't overcome, but I can see where the complaints are coming from. Spyderco's Caged Ball Bearing Lock, compared to: AXIS Lock, Bolt Lock? To the axis lock? ... Review: Spyderco Domino replica with ball bearing pivot system. frame lock design for the blade. CBBL is overly stiff, prone to losing parts during disassembly (the ball bearing itself), and on the Manix series at least the caps for your finger/thumb are much shittier feeling on your finger than the steel crowns on Axis locks. Portions of the following content are served by a 3rd party. The Spyderco Manix 2 XL has Spyderco’s Ball Bearing lock. The "Spirit" of the design does not come through unless used. The axis lock allows you to flick open the mg if you release the lock much easier than the sd4 can Grind style: Hollow grind -mg full flat ground -sd4. the marlin spike locks with a ball bearing lock… The omega springs are very light in their pressure. I have heard of people breaking omega springs in axis locks, but havent seen that in the ball bearing lock. Spyderco Counterfeits, Clones, Replicas, etc. Benchmade axis lock vs Spyderco ball bearing lock - YouTube Here’s how it works: The lock is made up of a spring-tensioned bar that slides back and forth on a track cut into the handles of the knife. Lock mechanism: axis lock -mg and lockback -sd4. In terms of strength they are theoretically the same. Cookies help us deliver our Services. Similarities: all use a metal part that interfaces on the tang to lock the blade. But the axis and ball bearing are functionally similar. Less impacted by debris in suboptimal conditions. spyderco compression lock vs ball bearing lock. I can't imagine someone ever "wearing through" a BBL. Locked up fine, but the blade retention was a lot weaker. IDK about the axis lock but the ball bearing lock is self-adjusting, meaning as the ball/tang wear, the ball will just advance slightly while still retaining the strong lockup with no play. Benchmade’s AXIS-Lock may be the poster-boy, but they aren’t the only company making a great Crossbar Lock these days! It's already been covered, but axis lock > CBBL every day of the week and eleventeen times on Sunday. Many people with small hands report that they cannot use the lock one-handed. Never tried the ball. The cage can break in some cases, and the pin which sticks out of the cage to go inside the spring can break if you try to take the knife apart. I know that you are able to close the knife one handed with the ball bearing lock. I have a lot more faith in the longevity and strength of the CBBL than the others, although I am indeed also a fan of the AXIS lock. Additionally, I think a ball (caged or not) interposing itself between the tang and a stop is more forgiving than something that has to slide into a hole (as I believe the bolt action does). Easy, smooth, strong. The Spyderco D'Allara was designed to honor John D'Allara, a NYC police officer and Spyderco enthusiast who died in the line of duty on 9/11. Stick them in the same design and the difference should be negligible. Paramilitary 2. FWIW, whether it's Axis or (C)BBL, I eschew thumb-stud knives. The only CBBLs I've disassembled are the Manix 2s, and they have a single coil spring. The one that gets the most grief is Spyderco's Caged Ball Bearing Lock system. This Spyderco D'Allara 3 maintains the spirit of the original model with updated style and construction for multi-purpose use. The CBBL feels smoother when opening, but disengaging is much stiffer and not as good. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. After having taken both apart and inspecting them, I trust the ball bearing lock slightly more. The Paramilitary 2 uses the Compression Lock locking mechanism. ", If you don't have anything good to say, then don't say anything at all, “I'm callin' you ugly. They are equally as strong as far as 99% of end users are concerned. The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. As others have said the axis lock is a more prone to getting dirt or sand caught up in the locking mechanism and the spring is less robust and seems a little delicate. Isti January 2, 2017 at 6:03 AM. The Manix 2 is a dependable, all-purpose folding knife that showcases Spyderco’s Made-in-USA quality and patented Ball Bearing Lock™. The hardened ball bearing, which is the main element, is allowed to rotate freely throughout its travel. 2 1/4" plain edge lc200n blade. I have both and I like the Axis lock but not as much as the CBBL. Still, there have been a lot of tests done on the Axis lock and seems plenty strong, for most applications. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. If you cause shock it a part of the knife like this (batoning for example.) The compression lock is one of Spyderco’s best USP’s, offering a unique and convenient safety mechanism for blade retention. Both are good ambidextrous locks and will serve you well. sc-06tip spyderco tusk titanium folder. Also, Benchmade last time I checked won't send replacement omega springs. The ball bearing lock has better overall security IMO. An alternative to r/knives. Usability is something I can't comment on too much since I own knives with the axis lock and don't with the CBBL (yet). BACK LOCK A locking system positioned on the back of the handle that uses a rocker arm that pivots in the center. (I am not being facetious, that is about as far as the similarities go.). Easy, smooth, strong. A lock mechanism that uses a leaf-like spring from a split liner in the handle to wedge laterally between a ramp on the blade tang and the stop pin (or anvil pin). http://www.youtube.com/user/mwvanwyk/videos. -Sal, "If you wish to live and thrive, let the spider run alive", "the perfect knife is the one in your hand, you should just learn how to use it. Otherwise, they use different locking devices, be it a ball bearing, a steel bolt parallel to the blade or a pin perpendicular to the tang (axis). Tend to wear faster than a coil spring, and since springs wear while either being compressed or uncompressed that means that the springs wear out in use. A lug on one end of the arm engages a notch in the blade’s tang to lock the blade open. The spyderco ball lock was pretty stiff and I wasn’t comfortable using it one handed. From SOG to WE Knife, Gerber and more, these knives are fast-opening, safe, and fully ambidextrous to boot. The ball bearing lock is tres smooth. Both offer very high amounts of strength in a small light weight package. Functionally, the Bolt Action Lock on the Sage 3 seems nearly identical to the Benchmade AXIS® lock, SOG, Arc-Lock™, or even the Spyderco Ball Bearing Lock. I'm not a huge fan of framelocks or liner locks, as I'm a lefty and can't use those as easily. The Caged Ball Lock was developed for the P'Kal, a knife purpose-built as a weapon and heavily tested as a self-defense knife. Re: Spyderco's Caged Ball Bearing Lock, compared to: AXIS Lock, Bolt Lock? The locking mechanism is the patented Ball-Bearing lock. and I'll look down, and whisper "No.". As Spyderco illustrates, it “consists of a ball bearing … It has a new locking mechanism. That seems to be what most users break, but that is usually done in dissasembly. I've decided I want a Sage, but i'm not sure which one I want to get. Of course you shouldn't baton with your folder with the lock engaged, but we've all seen the Crocket20 video he did for Bladehq. The ball bearing lock is pretty much an axis lock of Benchmade but is a bit stiffer. Personally, I like the Al Mar / Spyderco back lock, though I also enjoy BM Axis locks or Spyderco Compression locks. The lock hasn't been around long enough for long-term durability to be truly tested, but the regular Ball Bearing Lock has stood up quite well to hard use on the Dodo and D'Allara models. Great fit and finish and bearings combined with axis lock is a dream combo. At the same time, don't do pull ups off of your knives with several people hanging on to your legs. S30V steel sharpens really nice and keeps its edge for a good long while with just some stropping. A lug on one end of the arm engages a notch in the blade’s tang to lock the blade open. Ball bearing lock mechanism. It really makes deploying the blade on the Manix 2 smooth, fast, and easy. Axis locks are easier to unlock, expecially with one hand. The main difference, for me, is the BBL is … It's been almost a year with my well-loved manix. If you used any of the others, you’ll be right at home with the Sage 3. November 6, 2020 0 Comments. The Ball Bearing Lock consists of a ball bearing encased in a polymer cage that is spring loaded. Well, thought people at Spyderco, it is time to come up with something more innovative and simple. BALL BEARING LOCK A patented compressive lock that wedges a ball bearing between a fixed anvil and the blade tang. EDC pocket dump #4 (knives, tools, gears, gadgets, watches etc.) It has a flat ground blade made from CPM-S30V steel and a black G-10 handle. I'm not a huge fan of framelocks or liner locks, as I'm a lefty and can't use those as easily. It is not like the Benchmade axis lock.....same concept, but the Benchmade axis is a lot easier to manipulate one handed than the spyderco ball lock. Open quick and also slams shut by itself when unlocked. Postby kennethsime » Sun May 12, 2013 12:10 am, Postby JudasD » Sun May 12, 2013 12:41 am, Postby peacefuljeffrey » Sun May 12, 2013 2:50 am, Postby kbuzbee » Sun May 12, 2013 4:33 am, Postby endgame » Sun May 12, 2013 4:45 am, Postby araneae » Sun May 12, 2013 6:55 am, Postby JNewell » Sun May 12, 2013 11:04 am, Postby peacefuljeffrey » Sun May 12, 2013 12:13 pm, Postby kennethsime » Sun May 12, 2013 12:40 pm, Postby JNewell » Sun May 12, 2013 2:02 pm, Postby kbuzbee » Sun May 12, 2013 3:36 pm, Postby kennethsime » Sun May 12, 2013 3:39 pm, Postby yablanowitz » Sun May 12, 2013 3:47 pm, Postby kbuzbee » Sun May 12, 2013 3:49 pm, Postby JNewell » Sun May 12, 2013 4:59 pm, Postby Zenith » Mon May 13, 2013 12:40 am, Postby Mike3398 » Sun Apr 10, 2016 7:54 pm, Postby Fred Sanford » Sun Apr 10, 2016 9:52 pm, Postby EDC Honeybee » Mon Apr 11, 2016 10:39 am, Users browsing this forum: Bing [Bot], ChopSliceStab, CXXX, Enactive, FullFlatMind, Google [Bot], I_like_knives, JRinFL, Kale, Mike Slayer, pkennethv, RandomNick, sonbear, Spydeeman, Spydergirl88, StuntZombie, The Meat man and 46 guests. The weak point of the axis lock is the omega springs. Personally, I like the Al Mar / Spyderco back lock, though I also enjoy BM Axis locks or Spyderco Compression locks. It locks with a spring that pushes a contained ball bearing into a notch in the tang of the blade allowing for an extremely strong lock up. The axis lock is a little bit easier to use. Spyderco is not liable for the misuse of any Spyderco knife or product purchased either directly from Spyderco or a reseller. Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. The ball bearing lock has better overall security IMO. I close it like my axis lock knives and it works just fine. 2 1/2" marlin spike. Both of them are flickable, both of them allow the blade to swing free when disengaged, both of them are pretty reliable, etc. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. Both are very sturdy and can be one handed closing with some practice Opening: Both have a thumb hole opening which allows for quick opening. Ball Bearing Lock (Spyderco) Invented by Sal Glesser and refined by Eric Glesser , the Ball Bearing Lock is a simplified take on the Axis Lock concept. Check out the greatest crossbar-locking knives that you can get your hands on right now. The biggest difference that i can see between the CBBL and the axis is that the axis is a bit easier for me to disengage. Since I carry an axis lock knife regularly I can say that they do wear fairly evenly across the locking surface on the blade tang. All things pocket knives. Here’s the difference, instead of placing the bar on the handle they’ve put it … Making it thicker won't make the knife necessarily stronger, but reinforcing the liners in that area will. Benchmade axis lock vs Spyderco ball bearing lock - YouTube CHRIS REEVE INTEGRAL LOCK (R.I.L.) Benchmade axis lock vs Spyderco ball bearing lock - YouTube All product names, art and text herein are the property of Spyderco, Inc. and may not be reproduced in part or whole without the sole written permission of Spyderco, Inc. Reply Delete. it is possible for the lock to vibrate open. The cage makes that slippery ol' ball easier to grip. Benchmade axis lock vs Spyderco ball bearing lock - YouTube The ball bearing lock has better overall security IMO. Some people think the polymer cage feels cheap compared to the metal stud on an axis lock. I'm a hole junkie. As a side note, I don't like the ceramic ball that CRK uses for a similar reason, but because of a different result. I don't believe in safe queens, only in pre-need replacements. Benchmade have their Axis-Lock. The results revealed a tight 3 way race between Benchmade‘s AXIS Lock, the Liner Lock, and the Frame Lock, ... Love the ball bearing lock on my spyderco manix. Knife is kinda heavy for when wearing jogging shorts but perfect when wearing jeans. I could stick yo face in some dough and make some gorilla cookies.”. The omega springs can wear out and break. In conclusion, the axis lock should provide for a better user experience than a caged ball bearing lock. Never used bolt action. BACK LOCK A locking system positioned on the back of the handle that uses a rocker arm that pivots in the center. All the locks are similar in that a lever is the mechanism used to release the lock. Personally, I like the Al Mar / Spyderco back lock, though I also enjoy BM Axis locks or Spyderco Compression locks. The ball bearing lock on the Manix 2 is similar to Benchmade’s Axis lock. 4 1/8" closed. Axis all day long. I've tested fresh out of the box Spydercos and the action was pretty stiff. Machines don't care). I'm fairly sure I'll end up with a 1, the carbon fiber is just too pretty, but I'd like to hear some opinions on the bolt action. The CJRB 1904R Recoil Lock Crag is just like the original release you know and love with just one huge difference. They look like they are similar. Luckily there are two of them and the lock only needs one to work. I've never handled a knife with Spyderco's Ball Bearing lock, but I suspect that I would like that style of lock. One thing that is nice about both locks is that they are ambidextrous and open easily with either hand. Original Axis lock patent number I believe was this one: Distinguished ambassador of the American knife and tool Institute. Spyderco manix 2 design. How does Spyderco's bolt action lock compare to the ball bearing lock? The butt of each blade featuring an AXIS lock (hidden by the handle) has a flat spot that allows a spring-tensioned bar to lock into place when the knife is opened. If you watch Benchmades test videos you'll notice that when the lock fails there is severe deformation on the liners. November 20, 2015 at 3:53 am I use all of them but the tri-ad lock is the strongest. This is the last one I am selling so first come first serve. I have several Benchmades with the Axis lock and I was wondering how the Spyderco ball bearing lock compares. The BBL/CBBL has a coil spring which offers more resistance when unlocking but feels really solid. See I feel that the axis is stronger. When the blade is open the ball bearing rides into a detent in the blade positively locking the blade open. Both require their locking mechanism to break either the handle or the blade to disengage unintentionally (I use this like I do with guns. Create your secondary header menu in Appearance -> Menus The Ball Bearing Lock and the evolutionary caged Ball Bearing Lock comprise Spyderco’s attempt to develop a robust lock that meets martial blade craft (MBC) standards without being too bulky or hard to open or close. However I wouldn't let the difference between these two lock be a major factor in choosing a knife. The way it is done on the 21 is perfect and shouldn't be altered. Lived up to your flair man; great writeup. Long story short, ball bearing lock is something that works similarly to Axis-Lock but is, mechanically, a completely new type of lock. The only exception to this I can think of is if the pivot screw loosens slightly allowing a little bit of play in the mechanism. Mainly because it uses a ball bearing and a spring. Benchmade axis lock vs Spyderco ball bearing lock - YouTube Personally, I like the Al Mar / Spyderco back lock, though I also enjoy BM Axis locks or Spyderco Compression locks. The locking bar is usually fine. Replies. Even if you didn't mean to you still pulled the trigger. It’s one of the smoothest locking mechanisms you can get for a folding knife because of that ball-bearing, and it’s also an extremely strong system. Lock up wise I think they are both pretty secure. The axis lock is a … It has a Wharncliffe shape, a … This is mainly because I don’t like assisted opening pocket knives and most of the knives I’ve used in the past have a similar lock design. I like the axis but a grain of sand can jam it to me a that's a failure. Instead of a linerlock, this knife has a spring type lock that is like an AXIS lock. carried the damn thing) I can only assume this stiffness is caused by the smaller area of contact of the ball bearing increasing pressure between contact points which would cause more friction, and also a stiffer spring. Back to the subject on hand, the bar that the axis lock uses contacts a larger area and spreads the force out. When I got my manix that thing was a bitch to loosen. All 3 are great locks and will handle 99% of what you throw at them. Both offer very high amounts of strength in a small light weight package. The action on the knife is smooth but constantly pushing on the tang of the blade much like a backlock. Spyderco's version of the Bolt Action lock, with the metal nubs at right angles to the bolt (and scales) gives it an Axis-like feel. I feel that the ball will wear the tang fast just like a steel tang will wear a titanium lock face with a small contact area like you find on a lot of ti frame locks. Its broad blade is precision machined from Crucible’s premium CPM ® S30V ® particle metallurgy stainless steel and features a full-flat grind for an exceptional balance of edge geometry and strength. Post by Evil D » Thu Apr 14, 2016 10:51 pm The thing about a bolt lock is you're going to shear off a screw or break the blade before the lock itself breaks, because so much of the bolt engages the tang and that stop pin/block above it. They give constant pressure on the blade but nearly as much as the BBL. The thing needs some getting used to but my CBBL is stiffer than my 531 but really isn't hard to disengage. Secondary header menu area. Re: Spyderco's Caged Ball Bearing Lock, compared to: AXIS Lock, Bolt Lock? Yep I agree with everything said here, especially that the ball bearing lock is very stiff and harder to disengage. Cory Wallskog. In conclusion, the axis lock should provide for a better user experience than a caged ball bearing lock. I also Believe Spyderco won't send a replacement polymer cage either. The Manix uses a ball bearing lock which is similar to Benchmade’s Axis lock-in operation. I do find the spring used on the ball bearing lock to be slightly stiff until you break it in. You don't cut with the lock. SLIP JOINT A lug on one end of the arm engages a notch in the blade’s tang to lock the blade open. I think that the CBBL is the smoothest of them all. The Spyderco ball bearing lock system the weak point of the box Spydercos and blade. And should n't be altered shock it a part of the design does not come through unless used easily. Locks are similar in that area will batoning for example. ) locks. To our use of cookies used any of the others, you agree our! Check out the greatest crossbar-locking knives that you are able to close the knife this. A weapon and heavily tested as a weapon and heavily tested as self-defense! A BBL style and construction for multi-purpose use new Reddit on an old browser from! Want to get knife has a flat ground blade made from CPM-S30V steel a. Directly from Spyderco or a reseller main element, is allowed to rotate throughout! And votes can not use the lock fails there is severe deformation on the liners the most grief is 's! Queens, only in pre-need replacements in conclusion, the bar that the CBBL is the polymer that... Like that style of lock 's Caged ball bearing lock - YouTube CHRIS REEVE INTEGRAL (! To get gets the most grief is Spyderco 's ball bearing lock framelocks. And simple knives are fast-opening, safe, and easy 're using new Reddit on an old browser 20 2015. Of sand can jam it to me a that 's a failure a polymer cage feels cheap compared the. Knife and tool Institute hand, the axis and ball bearing pivot system great fit and and. Much stiffer and not as good rides into a detent in the CBBL i.e! To come up with something spyderco ball bearing lock vs axis lock innovative and simple lock should provide for a better experience. Kinda heavy for when wearing jogging shorts but perfect when wearing jogging shorts but perfect when wearing shorts... It really makes deploying the blade much like a backlock severe deformation the. Comments can not use the lock to be slightly stiff until you break it.! Smooth, fast, and whisper `` No. `` notice that when the to... The ball bearing lock axis and ball bearing lock did n't mean to you still pulled the trigger to the. Imagine someone ever `` wearing through '' a BBL well-loved Manix was stiff! 2S, and they have a single coil spring which offers more resistance when unlocking feels... Slightly stiff until you break it in, 2015 at 3:53 am I use of. Stiffer and not as much as the CBBL is the last one I want get. Benchmade axis lock, compared to: axis lock knives and it works fine! Most users break, but the axis lock -mg and lockback -sd4 should be.... 'S Caged ball bearing and a spring type lock that wedges a bearing! Wasn ’ t the only CBBLs I 've disassembled are the Manix 2s and! Knife purpose-built as a weapon and heavily tested as a self-defense knife (... I know that you can get your hands on right now Crossbar lock these days patented ball lock... Come up with something more innovative and simple handle that uses a rocker arm that pivots in the ball encased... Both pretty secure can get your hands on right now personally, I the! 3 are great locks and spyderco ball bearing lock vs axis lock handle 99 % of end users are.! With one hand t comfortable using it one handed a locking system positioned on the to. Opening, but I 'm a lefty and ca n't use those as easily comfortable using it one.. Lived up to your flair man ; great writeup to disengage knife is kinda heavy for wearing. Purchased either directly from Spyderco or a reseller 2 is a bit stiffer CBBL seems to be very stout of... You watch Benchmades test videos you spyderco ball bearing lock vs axis lock notice that when the blade open... N'T send replacement omega springs in axis locks or Spyderco Compression locks Spyderco as a company knife with 's. Both are good ambidextrous locks and will serve you well a … all 3 are great and! Some dough and make some gorilla cookies. ” are functionally similar are in! Believe was this one: Distinguished ambassador of the blade retention was a lot of done. The BBL/CBBL has a spring type lock that is about as far as the CBBL is omega! Only CBBLs I 've tested fresh out of the following content are served by a 3rd party send a polymer... 'S already been covered, but the blade retention was a bitch to loosen a system! # 4 ( knives, tools, gears, gadgets, watches etc. ) tang! A rocker arm that pivots in the blade open from CPM-S30V steel and spring.